DINNER MENU

– REYNOLDSBURG

Other Reynoldsburg Menus: Lunch | Happy Hour & Drink | Catering
Dinner is served 3 p.m. to close Monday – Saturday, all day Sunday, and upon request.

Appetizers


Bar-B-Que Ribs

Our Award Winning pork loin baby back ribs basted in our homemade sauce

8.95

Hickory House Wings

Ten breaded wings served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce or Buffalo sauce

8.95

Sweet Corn Nuggets

Sweet creamed style corn dipped in a light crispy batter and served with homemade ranch.

8.95

Onion Straws

Flash fried and served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce.

Full Order

5.50


Half Order

3.75

Shrimp Cocktail

Five jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge.

11.95

Grilled Shrimp

Four succulent shrimp broiled or Bar-B-Qued with Creole dipping sauce.

 

9.95

Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp

Four jumbo shrimp fried golden brown, served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge.

7.95

Hickory Chips

Topped with cheddar and bacon bits, served with our famous Bar-B-Que sauce

  Full Order

9.95


Half Order

7.95

Soups


French Onion Soup Au Gratin

Made from scratch daily.

4.95

Soup of the Day

Made from scratch daily.

4.95

Salads


Dinner Salad

  Small

4.50


Large

7.95

Steakhouse Salad

Grilled steak, mixed field greens, diced tomato, onion, sliced almonds and crumbled Blue Cheese.

13.95

Signature Salad

Garden fresh greens tossed with House dressing, crumbled Blue Cheese and real bacon.

Small

5.95


Large

9.95

Caesar Salad

Small

5.50


Large

8.95

Cobb Salad

Fresh greens, turkey, tomato, bacon, hard boiled egg and crumbled Blue Cheese.

11.95

Grilled Chicken & Cranberry Salad

Grilled chicken served over mixed field greens with cranberry craisins, sliced almonds, red onion and Blue Cheese; tossed with raspberry vinaigrette.

13.95

 

Add to Any Salad:

Chicken Breast 3.95 Steak 5.95 Salmon 5.95

Dressings:

House (sweet & sour with onion), French, Italian, Homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Ranch, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Homemade Blue Cheese (.95 extra), Crumbled Blue Cheese (.95 extra)

 

Sandwiches



Served with hand cut fries and a Kosher pickle.

Hickory's Best

Flame broiled half pound burger topped with American Cheese and bacon, served with lettuce, tomato and onion.

10.95

cheeseburger

9.95

hamburger

8.95

Tony Burger

Flame broiled half pound burger topped with BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese, cole slaw and a crisp onion ring.

10.95

Mushroom Burger

A half pound burger with mozzarella and mushrooms.

10.95

Chicken Breast Sandwich

Served broiled, Bar-B-Qued or buffalo style, on a Kaiser roll with lettuce and tomato.

9.95

Submarine Sandwich

Ham, salami, mozzarella, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers and our special sauce.

 

10.95

Pulled Pork Sandwich

Hand pulled, tossed with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce and served on a Kaiser Roll.

9.95

Haddock Sandwich

Served battered or breaded.

9.95

with cheese

10.95

Seafood



Includes potato or vegetable and dinner salad.

North Atlantic Salmon

Eight ounces served broiled with herb butter or Bar-B-Que glaze.

19.95

Butterflied Jumbo Shrimp

Six jumbo shrimp fried golden crisp and served with a lemon wedge and cocktail sauce.

17.95

Grilled Shrimp Dinner

Six succulent shrimp lightly seasoned and flame broiled. Served with Creole tarter sauce.

 

21.95

Haddock

Ten ounces served broiled, breaded or battered.

17.95

Steak, Chops & Chicken



All entrees include choice of potato or vegetable and dinner salad.

Filet Mignon

Completely trimmed center cut.

8oz

27.95

New York Strip

Fourteen ounce boneless center cut.

28.95

Signature Cut Pork Chops

Two center cut, seven ounce chops broiled or Bar-B-Qued to perfection.

19.95

Pasta Rossi

Sautéed chicken, mushrooms and penne pasta tossed in a light roasted red pepper cream sauce, then baked with a toasted Parmesan crust. Includes dinner salad only.

16.95

Top Sirloin

Eight ounce center cut.

18.95

Ribeye

Fourteen ounce, tender, full of flavor.

28.95

Ground Sirloin

Choice ground sirloin topped with sautéed onions.

16.95

Boneless Chicken Breasts

Two six ounce breasts served broiled or Bar-B-Qued.

15.95

Bar-B-Qued Meatloaf

Served over garlic mashed potatoes and topped with onion straws; served with the fresh vegetable of the day and dinner salad.

 

15.95

House Specialty


Porterhouse Steak

Two best quality cuts on one bone.

24.95


 

An Excellent Addition to Your Steak:

Sautéed Mushrooms 3.25 Sautéed Onions 2.50 Sautéed Mushrooms & Onions 3.00 Blue Cheese 2.00

Rare - Red Center, Cool | Medium Rare - Red Center, Warm | Medium - Pink Center, Warm | Medium Well - Hot, Juicy Center | Well - Dry, Not responsible
 

Award Winning Ribs



Choice Pork Loin Baby Back Ribs seasoned in our seven-spice rub, slow cooked and basted in our Homemade Sauce. Fall-off-the-bone delicious!

Slab Dinner

A full slab of our famous baby back ribs.

21.95

Rib Dinner

A half slab of our famous baby back ribs.

 

18.95

 

The Best Rack in Town

Carry Out Ala Carte Slab Only

16.95

 

 

Our Combos



Can't Decide? Try a little of everything! Choose from the following:


Top Sirloin | Bar-B-Qued Ribs | Butterflied or Grilled Shrimp | Broiled or Bar-B-Qued Boneless Chicken Breast

Pick Two (2) 23.95

 

Signature Combos


Filet & Shrimp

Filet mignon paired with a skewer of our succulent grilled shrimp.

8oz

30.95

Filet & Ribs

Filet mignon paired with our award winning ribs.

  8 oz

30.95


Sides



All sides 2.50
 
 

Desserts


Cookie Skillet 7.95
Ice Cream Sundae
No Sugar Added Vanilla Ice Cream 3.95
Seasonal Cakes & Pies from Ohio’s Der Dutchmen Amish Bakery 5.95

Kid's Menu



For our guests 12 years old and younger. All kid's meals served with hand cut fries, applesauce and a beverage.

 
 

Homemade Dressings and Sauces by the Jar

Bar-B-Que Sauce 4.50
House Sweet & Sour Dressing 3.95
Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing 4.95
Seven-Spice Rib Seasoning 4.50
Homemade Ranch Dressing 3.95


Hickory House Gift Cards

Gift Cards available in all denominations.
No expiration dates.

Catering

Full service lunch, dinner & event catering available at both locations.
Banquets available at our Gahanna location.
See our Catering Menu